My Palanca copy needs a bit of explanation.
There are many excellent flutes in the world that are derived from the Palanca original. They are really excellent flutes and played by many excellent proffessional players. However, although these flutes are excellent instruments they are also somewhat different from original baroque flutes and therefore the subject of taste discussions. The Palanca copies I make are close to the original. This especially with respect to the possibilities of the dynamics and coloring the tone. So far for me reactions have been convincing and were like "this Palanca I can play" (famous Paris player) to this is the best you make (famous Japanese player). For me it was very surprising that the changes I needed to make for a really excellent intonation were easy. However, that also makes for a difference with the original. Nvertheless, at the NFA in Chicago a Palanca original was present. Your Palanca plays like that original was the comment of a famous Belgian player at the convention.
This is what I am trying to achievce. If players then like it is up to them!
I am copying the Palanca from a private collection in Frankfurt.
Picture of the original.
For the owner the pitches are 417/427/435 Hz However, for most players the pitches are essentially higher, about 421, 431 and 439Hz.
I have recalculated the pitch 421 to 417. So far for everybody this was satisfactory for 415, usually pulling out a little bit of course.
From "The new Langwill index"
Palanca. Carlo (b 1688/90; Torino 23 December1783) maker in Torino 1719-1783.
17I9 until 70 'Suonatore di bassa d'Autbois'(bassoonist) at the Royal Chapel of
Torino' colleague of the famous Besozzi oboist brothers, with whom as maker he was closely associated;
1748 supplied '4 flauti. 3 flagioletti & 2 piffori' for 33 lire; 1755 two ‘raliantini' were ordered from him;
1773 received order from Lisboa Court Chapel for two oboes;
1783 died at age 95. His will is preserved at I-Torino-AST.
MARK: CARLO / PALANCA
BIBLIOGRAPHY: Bernardini in FD 13.22, Wind in Tibia
1/86J8. Youns 1993, Bernardini (private communication).